This case was voted for by our Patreon Besties.
Michelle von Emster, 25, was found dead off the coast of San Diego in 1994 after two surfers discovered her body.
Her right leg was missing from mid-thigh, she had extensive wounds, a broken neck, and sand was found in her stomach and other organs. Investigators initially concluded she had been killed by a great white shark.
However, some experts later argued that her injuries were inconsistent with a shark attack, leaving the exact circumstances of her death disputed.